Skip to content

Gender Karma in Spiritual Communities

Jaya Kula students
August 25 2016

The Hindu pantheon of deities presents us with a playground of playfully shifting gender expressions.  Nonetheless, the force of conventional gender role expectations and confusion plays itself out everywhere, including in spiritual communities.

The group of traditions and lineages that comprise what is called “Hinduism,” and Tantra, include the worship of deities that manifest all of the conventional gender roles. But we also have male deities who appear in half-male/ half-female forms, or even who show up as all-female at times. We have dancing male deities and male deities who give birth. We have female deities who ride lions and tigers and are fiercer warriors than their male counterparts. Everybody gets to wear jewelry and grow their hair long.

A rare image of Sri Vidya Ganesha - a female form of Ganesha

A rare image of Shri Vidya Ganesha, a female form of Ganesha

My Guru, Anandamayi Ma, at times incarnated as Durga or Chinnamasta, both female deities, and, at other times as Krishna or Lord Shiva.

And in contrast to many other spiritual traditions, in the classical Indian Tantrik traditions, the female aspect is the active principle of creative power or energy, and the male aspect is the passive, feeling-consciousness principle, also called the Host. Shakti rides on or emerges from the supine Host, Lord Shiva, to create the world.

While we talk about the Shiva and Shakti aspects of Reality as separate, in fact, they are always together and must both be realized in full by each person.



When we look at our actual, lived condition, many women have been taught to supress their fierceness, and many men don’t know how to host.

This must be approached as sadhana.

In many spiritual communities, women and more shakti-identified men do most of the engaged hosting and maintaining work. Some men prefer to remain more on the sidelines, supporting in ways such as by giving money, or just by showing up.

Believe it or not, there are still many young and/or progressive men who feel it is beneath them, or not worth their time to do the hands-on work of supporting their communities. And despite what the ancient tradition has to say, male peers often act out their assumed privilege and communicate in subtle and not-so-subtle ways their conception of women as lesser than.

Women are more reluctant to speak up, take teaching roles or in general take responsibility for having done a lot of sadhana and realized. Women intentionally round-off the edges of their clarity and  hold back their “shine,” so as not to provoke disapproval.

Anandamayi Ma incarnating Lord Krishna

Anandamayi Ma incarnating Lord Krishna

In our Jaya Kula community, even hip, young women are sometimes  reluctant to take on jobs that are culturally coded as male, for instance, helping to set up our electronic devices (computer, camera, mic) for our live-stream broadcasts. Women students find it harder, in general, to let someone have a difficult moment without rushing in to offer comforting hugs or words, and they often demand these from others.

Even our emotional displays are products of gender karma. Women are more likely to resort to tears, sadness and silent resentment. Men are more likely to resort to displays of anger, dismissiveness, bullying and checking out with media binging and porn.

Gender karma is the most fundamental, pervasive karma.

Gender connects us to the most fundamental Reality: that of the possibility of having an experience of separation and then of coming together again.

This possibility is encoded into Reality in the living metaphor of Shiva and Shakti, the eternal couple that is always together in an absolute sense, but experiences the pulse of separation and reunion as playfulness in the field of manifest life.

Gender karma comes into play when we are experiencing separation from our fundamental nature. We recognize the separation, but not the more fundamental continuity. In this circumstance, we are anything but playful.

The first step is to understand that male and female are co-arising karmas. Men are not causing women to be a certain way, and women are not causing men to be a certain way. The gender karma of men, women and everything in between, is ONE circumstance that we are all living through together. We are a whole expressing itself as parts and yearning for reunion.

The second step is to begin to recognize gender karma patterns as they operate in spiritual communities and in our individual lives.  Once we recognize a pattern, it naturally begins the process of unwinding over time under the influence of continued sadhana.

In the ancient Tantras, it is said that men must learn to be Shakti. I think we are in a different situation today. Men have to relearn how to host the creative power of women and use their own power in more contemplative, supportive ways; women have to relearn how to more fully express their power and make worlds appear.

Ultimately, sadhana helps us to recognize all of the wisdom virtues of Reality within ourselves and to express them more fully. Then we can play with gender expressions, knowing them to be nothing but costumes of divine unity.


Photo is of students of Jaya Kula at our 2016 Tantrik Birthday Ball.